Car Deal Canada

Electric Cars and The Environment

Electric Cars and The Environment

Electric vehicles have been growing in popularity over the last decade. Major automakers are announcing new EV models, governments are setting aggressive electrification targets, and sales of plug-in electric cars reached over 6.5 million worldwide in 2021. But there is an ongoing debate around whether this shift towards electric mobility is actually better for the environment.


While electric vehicles eliminate tailpipe emissions, some argue the emissions from manufacturing the batteries and sourcing materials offset the gains. There are also concerns over the reliance on power plants, especially dirty coal generation. So are electric cars living up to their green reputation and role in reducing emissions from transportation?


Comprehensive research shows that when examining the full lifecycle impacts, electric vehicles are in fact better for the climate and environment compared to equivalent gas-powered vehicles. However, EVs are not completely emissions-free and do have some impacts from battery production and raw material sourcing that need to be improved through technological advances and responsible mining practices.

Get Pre-Qualified in Under 60 Seconds

All Credit Approved and 0 Money Down Options Available

 

Lifetime Emissions

When comparing the environmental impacts of electric vehicles and gas-powered vehicles, it’s important to look at the full lifecycle emissions rather than just tailpipe emissions. Lifecycle emissions encompass all greenhouse gas emissions associated with manufacturing, operating, and disposing of a vehicle throughout its lifetime. This includes emissions from extracting raw materials, manufacturing parts, assembling the vehicle, fueling/charging it, and end-of-life recycling or disposal.

Numerous studies have found that over their entire lifespan, battery electric vehicles generate around half the greenhouse gas emissions of an equivalent conventional gas-powered vehicle. According to the Union of Concerned Scientists, the average EV is responsible for global warming emissions equal to 50-70g CO2e per mile over its lifetime, while the average comparable gasoline car causes 280-350g CO2e per mile. The EPA estimates driving a typical EV in the US generates 42% fewer emissions than even the most efficient gas-powered car.

A significant portion of emissions from electric vehicles occurs during manufacturing, especially production of the battery pack. However, the avoided tailpipe emissions over the operational lifetime of the EV more than offset the increased manufacturing emissions. On average, it takes an EV driving between 20,000 – 40,000 miles to reach emissions parity with a gas vehicle, after which every additional mile driven accrues emissions benefits.

 

Power Plant Emissions

While electric vehicles have no direct tailpipe emissions, the electricity they use to charge does produce emissions at power plants. This simply shifts emissions from millions of individual vehicles to centralized power generation facilities. However, electricity generation is getting cleaner over time as grids shift towards more renewable sources like solar and wind.

In the past, a majority of electricity came from burning coal, a very carbon-intensive fuel source. But coal has been rapidly declining over the last decade. It has been replaced primarily by cleaner-burning natural gas and zero-emissions sources like solar, wind, hydro and nuclear. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, renewable energy sources are now projected to produce 22% of U.S. electricity in 2022, compared to just 11% in 2000.

So even though emissions may be concentrated at power plants, rapid changes in electricity generation are leading to an overall cleaner mix powering electric vehicles. Grids will continue to get greener as more renewables come online, further improving the emissions profile of EVs.

 

Emissions Impact Depends on Grid Mix

The emissions impact of electric vehicles depends heavily on the energy sources used to generate electricity in the grid. EVs charged in a region powered mostly by coal will have higher emissions than if charged where hydro, nuclear, wind and solar provide a large share of the electricity mix.

As grids add more renewable energy like wind and solar, emissions from EVs decrease substantially. Nuclear and hydro power are also zero-emission sources that help make EV charging cleaner. According to the Union of Concerned Scientists, in a grid supplied by at least 50% renewable sources, lifetime emissions from an electric vehicle become lower than a 50 mpg gasoline car.

The US grid is rapidly adding renewable energy and retiring coal plants. This steady “greening” of electricity will continue to reduce the emissions of electric vehicles in the future. Pairing the growth of EVs and renewable energy is an important strategy for reducing transportation sector emissions.

 

Raw Materials and Battery Impacts

There are valid concerns around the materials needed to manufacture electric vehicle batteries, especially lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Extracting these metals from the earth can have environmental and human rights impacts. However, steps are being taken to address these concerns:

 

– Battery recycling programs can help supply a portion of key metals like cobalt and lithium, reducing the need for new mining. As more electric vehicles reach end-of-life, a circular supply chain can be established.

– Research is underway on new battery chemistries that would reduce or eliminate reliance on certain scarce metals. Solid state batteries are one promising technology that may eventually replace lithium-ion.

– Responsible sourcing initiatives by automakers and battery suppliers aim to improve traceability and sustainability around material extraction. While there is more progress to be made, this demonstrates a commitment to ethical sourcing.

 

As with any new technology, challenges exist around raw materials and production. But the electric vehicle industry is actively working to develop more sustainable options for energy storage and make substantial reductions in emissions from transportation.

 

Responsible Sourcing Initiatives

There are growing efforts to improve transparency and sustainability around the sourcing of battery minerals like lithium and cobalt. Responsible sourcing initiatives aim to address environmental and human rights concerns in the extraction process.

For example, the Initiative for Responsible Mining Assurance (IRMA) has developed standards and certification programs for responsibly mined materials. Automakers like Ford and Volkswagen are partnering with organizations like RCS Global to audit their battery supply chains. The goals are to trace minerals back to environmentally and socially responsible sources.

Blockchain technology is also being used to track raw materials and verify responsible sourcing claims. Pilot projects are testing blockchain-based supply chain tracking for EV battery minerals. These initiatives help provide assurance that materials are ethically sourced.

While work remains to be done, responsible sourcing represents an important step towards improving sustainability across EV battery supply chains.

 

Widespread EV Adoption Enables Faster Transition

Widespread adoption of electric vehicles is a key part of transitioning away from gas-powered vehicles and their emissions more quickly. Many experts argue that the pace of phasing out conventional vehicles is just as important as the long-term emissions reductions from electric cars.

With ambitious EV adoption goals and scenarios, we can accelerate the transition away from internal combustion engine vehicles. For example, California has mandated that all new vehicles sold must be zero emissions by 2035. Other countries like Norway aim to end the sale of gas and diesel passenger vehicles by 2025. Targets like these will force automakers to shift production faster.

According to the International Energy Agency, electric vehicles need to make up at least 30% of new car sales by 2030 to stay on track with Paris climate goals. More optimistic scenarios have EVs reaching over 50% market share globally in the next decade. While those targets are ambitious, they highlight the importance of rapid EV growth to slash transportation emissions and mitigate climate change.

 

EV Technology Continues Improving

Advances in electric vehicle technology are making EVs more efficient and eco-friendly over time. Battery chemistries, powertrain design, lightweight materials, charging speed, and driving range have all been improving steadily.

Lithium-ion batteries continue to increase energy density, allowing more range from smaller, lighter battery packs. New chemistries like lithium iron phosphate help boost safety and lifespan. Regenerative braking converts kinetic energy to charge the battery while driving. Lightweight aluminum and carbon fiber construction increases efficiency.

One example is Tesla’s efficiency improvements, with the original 2012 Model S achieving 325 miles on a 75 kWh battery pack while the 2022 Model S can now reach 405 miles on a 100 kWh pack. Further innovations will enable continued range and efficiency gains.

Faster home, workplace, and public charging speeds allow EVs to recharge in minutes instead of hours. New extreme fast charging technologies can add hundreds of miles of range in just 15-30 minutes. This improves convenience and usability for consumers.

As technology progresses, electric vehicles are becoming more mainstream and accessible. With the performance gap continuing to close between EVs and gas vehicles, the environmental benefits shine through as a key advantage.

 

Pairing EVs with Cleaner Grid

Maximizing emissions reductions from EVs needs a cleaner grid. As more renewable energy sources like solar, wind, and hydropower are added to the electricity grid, charging an EV will utilize lower-carbon sources. Many utilities and states have goals to substantially increase renewables in the coming years. For example, New York has a target of 70% renewable electricity by 2030. California is aiming for 100% zero-carbon electricity by 2045. Even without new policies, market forces and economics are leading to coal declining while lower-carbon natural gas and zero-emissions wind and solar are increasing their share of the grid mix in most regions. Paired with a grid that keeps getting cleaner, the climate benefits of electric vehicles compound over time.

 

Electric Vehicles Part of Broader Changes Needed

While electric vehicles provide major emissions reductions compared to gas-powered cars, they are just one part of the larger societal and systems changes needed to fully address the climate crisis. Widespread EV adoption should be paired with complementary policies and approaches like denser, more walkable urban development, investments in public and active transit infrastructure, changes to city planning to reduce sprawl, and more distributed clean electricity generation.

Electric vehicles work best from an emissions standpoint when they are powered by a clean electricity grid and are driven fewer total miles because of greater access to public transit, biking, and walking options. Cities designed primarily around cars have more congestion, sprawl, and emissions. EVs paired with better urban design and transportation options as part of a holistic transition away from fossil fuels will maximize their benefits.

While EVs address emissions from daily driving, their role has limits. Broader changes to how our cities are built and how people get around are also needed to reduce the extensive emissions caused by traffic congestion and long commutes. EVs are one key tool, but work best when part of a larger toolkit to create more sustainable and livable cities.

 

Criticisms and Counterpoints

While electric vehicles provide significant emissions reductions over gas-powered cars, some criticisms about their manufacturing impact and material sourcing have emerged.

One concern often raised is that producing the battery for an electric vehicle generates more emissions than manufacturing a gas car engine. However, research shows this impact is rapidly offset. One study found the extra emissions from an EV battery are offset within the first 6,500 miles of driving. Over the total lifetime, an EV’s emissions are still much lower.

Another criticism involves the mining of raw materials like lithium and cobalt for EV batteries, which has environmental and human rights impacts. These are valid concerns, but recycling, responsible sourcing initiatives, and shifts to different battery chemistries can help address these problems.

Some argue EVs just shift emissions from the tailpipe to power plants. But even on today’s grids with coal power, EVs have lower lifetime emissions. And grids are getting cleaner, with coal declining and renewable energy expanding.

While worth considering, these concerns do not outweigh the considerable emissions reductions EVs provide over gas vehicles, especially as electricity generation continues to decarbonize. And the environmental impact of EVs will continue improving through technological advances.

 

Conclusion

In summary, comprehensive research shows that electric vehicles have substantially lower emissions and environmental impact compared to conventional gas-powered vehicles. Analyzing the full lifecycle, from manufacturing to usage, EVs generate about half the emissions of equivalent gas cars. The emissions from battery production are offset over the vehicle’s lifetime. While electric vehicles shift emissions from the tailpipe to power plants, electricity generation is getting cleaner over time with more renewables.

Electric cars do still have impacts from raw material sourcing for batteries, but technology improvements and recycling can help address these concerns. Initiatives for responsible and sustainable materials extraction are also advancing. As battery chemistries evolve and grids get cleaner, the emissions benefits of EVs will continue improving.

Widespread adoption of electric vehicles enables a faster transition away from gas cars and their high emissions levels. Paired with renewable energy sources, electric cars will play an integral role in reducing emissions from the transportation sector and creating a more sustainable future.

Get Approved Today

See if you qualify in under 60 seconds

Questions About EVs and The Environment

**Electric vehicles emit fewer greenhouse gases than gas-powered cars over their lifespan in Canada.** EVs charged from Canada’s relatively clean electricity grid produce less carbon emissions than average new gasoline cars. And as more renewable energy comes online, emissions drop further.

On average, electric vehicles charged on Canada’s grid produce about 66%-75% fewer carbon emissions over their lifespan compared to gas-powered vehicles. This makes them a better environmental option, especially as Canada’s electricity gets cleaner.

Yes, producing EV batteries is carbon-intensive. However, recent studies show that over an EV’s lifetime, the emissions savings from driving electric outweigh battery production emissions, especially as batteries get more efficient.

Some materials for EV batteries like lithium, cobalt and nickel can come from mines with poor labor and environmental practices. But many automakers and tech companies are working towards more responsible, ethical supply chains for battery materials.



Modern EV batteries retain around 70-80% of their capacity after 200,000+ km, even accounting for Canadian winters. With proper thermal management, battery degradation from extreme cold has vastly improved.

Yes, an EV’s range drops in very cold weather, sometimes up to 30-40%. But Canada’s EV charging network is continually expanding. And range loss from cold is temporary compared to long-term financial savings.

Around 60% of Canada’s electricity comes from renewable sources like hydroelectric dams or wind, 20% from nuclear, and just 15% from fossil fuels. So powering EVs here produces fewer emissions than countries more reliant on coal and gas plants.

Studies show Canada’s grid can support projected EV uptake without needing major upgrades soon. Smart charging technology can avoid overloading infrastructure. The grid may need strengthening in the longer term if EV adoption is very rapid.

Even if powered 100% by fossil fuels, analysis shows EVs would still produce less emissions than a conventional car over their lifespan. But Canada has one of the cleanest grids in the world, so real-world emissions from EV charging are very low here.

Purchase prices of new EVs are falling but still out of reach for many Canadians. However, used EVs are becoming more affordable. And government rebates, tax breaks and other incentives can also help make EVs attainable for more income levels.



It’s a common barrier, but solutions exist. Many workplaces, malls and public parking lots now have charging stations. Also, advocating for chargers in apartment/condo buildings helps. As the charging network develops, access will continue improving.

Maybe when EVs first came out. But Canada’s charging infrastructure is expanding fast as EV adoption rises. And smart charging platforms show wait times and stations in real-time. Overall, congestion is uncommon outside certain busy corridors.

Modern EVs can accelerate just as fast as sports cars! Even affordable models have responsive performance. Plus their lower center of gravity gives confident handling. The driving experience keeps getting better too – the age of dull EVs is over.

In very cold weather, charging an EV battery does take 15-30% longer. The battery must be warmed to an optimal temperature first before rapid charging can start. But with proper planning, the impact is manageable for most drivers’ needs.

Companies like Li-Cycle safely break down expired EV batteries at specialized recycling plants, recovering valuable battery materials for reuse. Canada is also researching ways to repurpose less degraded EV batteries for energy storage instead of disposal.

Federal and provincial governments do risk declining gas tax income as electric vehicles gain market share. But policy ideas like EV registration fees or road usage charges could help offset this loss in the longer term.

Rural EV use has some key obstacles still, namely limited charging access. But for drivers with workplace charging or who don’t drive long daily distances, rural ownership can work out. Many towns and businesses now install chargers to enable rural EV travel too.

Short range isn’t ideal for Canada’s vast distances between chargers. Long range all-wheel drive EVs like the Tesla Model Y, Ford Mustang Mach-E AWD or upcoming Chevrolet Equinox EV cope best with range anxiety and winter traction needs for Canadian driving conditions.



Get Approved Today

See if you qualify in under 60 seconds