Is The Fiat 500 Reliable?
The Fiat 500 is an iconic Italian subcompact that has captured the hearts of drivers worldwide with its cute, retro styling reminiscent of the original 1957 model. After a decades-long hiatus, Fiat reintroduced the 500 to North America in 2011, bringing its charming design and compact dimensions to a new generation of urbanites and city drivers.
While the Fiat 500’s quirky personality and fun-to-drive nature have earned it a loyal following, opinions on its reliability have been conflicting. Some owners rave about their 500’s dependability, while others lament frequent trips to the mechanic. This article aims to provide an in-depth, unbiased look at the reliability of the Fiat 500, helping Canadian drivers make an informed decision when considering purchasing one used.
Get Pre-Qualified in Under 60 Seconds
All Credit Approved and 0 Money Down Options Available
Fiat’s Reputation for Reliability
When it comes to Fiat’s reputation for reliability, the Italian automaker has long carried a stigma of producing vehicles plagued by quality issues and frequent breakdowns. This perception stems from the brand’s troubled history, particularly in the latter half of the 20th century, when Fiat vehicles were notorious for their poor build quality, unreliable components, and propensity for mechanical failures.
During those tumultuous times, Fiat’s factories were often criticized for lax quality control measures and outdated manufacturing processes, resulting in cars that simply couldn’t match the reliability standards set by their Japanese and German counterparts. Owners frequently reported issues with everything from faulty electrical systems and leaky gaskets to premature engine and transmission failures, further cementing Fiat’s reputation as a brand to be avoided if dependability was a priority.
However, in recent years, Fiat has made concerted efforts to shed this unfavorable image and regain the trust of consumers. Under the leadership of the Fiat Chrysler Automobiles (FCA) conglomerate, the company has implemented rigorous quality control protocols and invested heavily in modernizing its production facilities with state-of-the-art equipment and lean manufacturing techniques.
These measures have aimed to improve build quality, reduce defects, and enhance overall reliability across Fiat’s lineup. Additionally, the brand has embraced advanced engineering and technology, incorporating more robust and proven components sourced from reputable suppliers to bolster the durability of its vehicles.
An In-Depth Look at Fiat 500 Reliability Data
To assess the Fiat 500’s reliability, we must examine data from leading industry authorities. J.D. Power’s Vehicle Dependability Study rates the 500 around the middle of the pack for subcompact cars. While not stellar, it’s a decent showing for the quirky Italian model.
Consumer Reports tells a less favorable story, with the 500 scoring below average in their reliability ratings. They cite problems with the engine, transmission, and electrical systems as major trouble spots. The 500’s relatively high repair costs and frequency of repairs hurt its scores.
RepairPal data paints a similar picture of subpar reliability for the 500. Their analysis shows it requires more frequent unscheduled repairs than average, with an annual repair cost over $600 – higher than many other subcompacts on the market. Some of the most common issues reported include problems with the auxiliary water pump, engine control module failure, and excessive oil consumption.
While the 500’s reliability has improved in recent model years, its checkered history of recalls is another concern. Some of the major recalls have involved issues with the dual-clutch automatic transmission, engine software updates, and suspension components. Checking that any used 500 has had outstanding recalls addressed is essential.
Compared to class leaders like the Honda Fit, Toyota Yaris, and Hyundai Accent, the Fiat 500 consistently trails in reliability metrics. Its scores are more on par with other budget-focused models like the Nissan Versa and Mitsubishi Mirage. So while not a total lemon, the 500 is below the reliability standards set by its Japanese and Korean competitors in this segment.
Reliability Tips for Fiat 500 Owners
While the Fiat 500 has improved in reliability compared to the brand’s troubled past, there are still some key steps owners can take to maximize the longevity and dependability of their 500. Proper maintenance is critical, so be diligent about following the recommended service schedules for oil changes, fluid flushes, filter replacements, and inspections. Always use quality parts and fluids approved by Fiat.
It’s also wise to stay on top of any open recalls or technical service bulletins for your specific model year and engine. Addressing these potential issues proactively can prevent larger problems down the road. Avoid modifications or aftermarket accessories that could negatively impact reliability or void warranties.
When purchasing a used Fiat 500, simpler is often better from a reliability standpoint. The base 1.4L MultiAir engine and 5-speed manual transmission tend to have fewer reported issues than the automated manual or turbocharged Abarth variants. Stick with lower trim levels that have fewer complex electronic systems and features.
How you drive and care for the 500 matters too. Avoid excessive engine revving, hard acceleration, and abrupt braking. The 500’s small size and tight turning radius require extra care in parking lots. Be gentle when operating the manual transmission. And living in Canada’s climate extremes, proper winter storage, rust prevention, and using the right weight oil are musts.
Common Problems in the Fiat 500
While the Fiat 500 has its charms, it’s important for Canadian used car buyers to be aware of the common issues that have plagued certain model years and versions. Based on analysis of owner reports and mechanic insights, some 500 models are more prone to reliability problems than others.
The earliest models from 2011-2013 tend to be the least reliable Fiat 500s on the used market. These cars are more likely to experience issues with the dual-clutch automatic transmission, engine components like timing chains and valve train, electrical gremlins, and problems with the air conditioning system. The 2012 model year in particular stands out as having an above-average number of complaints related to transmission failures and electrical faults.
On the other hand, the 2014-2019 Fiat 500 models have a somewhat better track record for reliability, though they are still not on par with class leaders like the Honda Fit or Toyota Yaris. The 1.4L MultiAir engine introduced in 2014 has proven more durable than earlier powerplants. However, issues with the manual and automatic transmissions persist, along with some electrical bugs.
For maximum reliability when buying used, the 2015-2017 Fiat 500 Abarth hot hatch models are often cited as the “sweet spot” in terms of having the fewest complaints. The turbocharged 1.4L engine is robust, and the manual transmission holds up well. Just be wary of potential clutch wear on higher mileage Abarths due to the demands of the performance drivetrain.
The Bottom Line on Fiat 500 Reliability
After examining reliability data, owner reports, and expert analysis, it’s clear the Fiat 500 has come a long way in improving quality and dependability compared to the brand’s troubled past. However, it still trails behind class leaders like Honda, Toyota, and Hyundai when it comes to predicted reliability and long-term ownership costs.
Industry experts at Consumer Reports and J.D. Power give the 500 average-to-below-average reliability ratings, citing issues with the engines, transmissions, electrical systems, and in-car technology over time. While the cute Italian runabout can be a fun and stylish city car when new, it requires more diligent maintenance and repair costs can add up faster than mainstream rivals after a few years of ownership.
That said, Fiat has made strides in recent years by revamping manufacturing processes and quality control measures. The later models from 2015 onward tend to fare better in reliability surveys. So for Canadian drivers considering a used 500, focusing the search on low-mileage, well-maintained 2015+ examples could mitigate some of the reliability concerns. Avoid earlier models with the troublesome 1.4L MultiAir engines.
Ultimately, the Fiat 500 is an affordable and characterful city car choice for those prioritizing style and driving fun over predicted reliability and long-term operating costs. Just be prepared for more frequent repairs and shorter longevity compared to a used Honda Fit, Toyota Yaris or Hyundai Accent from a similar year. Proper maintenance is essential to maximize the 500’s lifespan.
Get Approved Today
See if you qualify in under 60 seconds
Questions About Fiat 500 Reliability
Is the Fiat 500 a reliable used car choice overall for Canadian drivers?
Based on the in-depth analysis in the blog post, the short answer is no – the Fiat 500 is not considered a very reliable used subcompact car overall compared to other mainstream brands popular with Canadian drivers. While Fiat has improved from their past reputation for poor quality, the 500 still scores below average in most industry reliability rankings and has a higher than typical rate of repairs needed outside the warranty period. It trails leading competitors like the Honda Fit or Toyota Yaris for longevity and problem-free ownership. Reliability also varies significantly between different engine options and model years of the 500, so meticulous inspection and maintenance is required to get the longest lifespan out of one. For most Canadian used car shoppers, a Fiat 500 carries more inherent reliability risks that should be carefully weighed before purchase.
What are the worst problem areas to watch out for on high-mileage Fiat 500 models?
Owners of older, high mileage Fiat 500 models report some consistent problem spots to keep an eye on as major repair bills waiting to happen outside of warranty coverage. These include issues with the dual clutch automated manual transmission, the electrical system, engine cooling system, turbochargers on performance trims, and oil leaks from the gasket seals. Repairs like a transmission replacement or turbo rebuild can run over $2000+ in some cases. Other vulnerable parts prone to premature failure include the water pump, ignition coils, battery, wheel bearings, and various sensors. Paying for a thorough pre-purchase inspection by a trusted mechanic on any high-mile 500 is strongly advised. Also try to obtain service records to know what’s been replaced already.
How does routine maintenance and proper care impact Fiat 500 reliability?
Due to its reputation for spotty reliability, the Fiat 500 requires diligent routine maintenance and proper care to reach high mileages problem-free. Follow the factory maintenance schedule closely, doing oil changes, fluid flushes, and inspections at the recommended intervals. Do not stretch changes out. Use quality synthetic oils and OEM or OEM-equivalent parts when repairs are needed. Keep records of all service work. Avoid engine-tuning mods that stress the powertrain. Drive smoothly and avoid excessive revving or speeding which can accelerate wear. Send in any outstanding recalls or TSB fixes. Keep it garaged if possible. Following these best practices helps maximize the 500’s longevity and minimize costly breakdowns.
What recall or technical service bulletin (TSB) issues should potential Fiat 500 buyers research?
It’s smart for any used Fiat 500 buyer to thoroughly research recalls and technical service bulletins (TSBs) issued for the model year they are considering. Some of the more significant recall issues to check for and ensure were addressed cover problems with the transmission shifter, airbag deployment, power steering, and fire risks. TSBs were released for issues including check engine light codes, loss of power, stalling, excessive oil use, warning lights, and electrical glitches among other glitches. Running a full recall/TSB history report and having a dealer check for any outstanding issues needing correction is vital due diligence before purchasing a used 500. Addressing these factory defect fixes often prevents bigger headaches down the road.
How much does it cost to insure a Fiat 500 in Canada compared to other small cars?
In Canada, Fiat 500 models are grouped into the higher insurance rate classifications given their statistically higher claims rates for collisions and repair costs compared to other small cars. Insurance quotes for a 500 can run $150-$300 higher annually over a Fit, Yaris or Accent. Comprehensive and collision premiums tend to be costly due to the high price of OEM parts. Factors like a driver’s age, location, and driving record impact rates as well. The good news is the 500 has excellent safety ratings to potentially lower injury liability coverage. Those buying a used 500 should get quotes from several providers to find the best rate. But overall, it is one of the more expensive small cars to insure in Canada currently.
Does the Fiat 500 have expensive maintenance requirements?
Overall maintenance costs on the Fiat 500 are not exceptionally high compared to other European subcompact luxury models, but are generally higher than basic mainstream brands renowned for affordability and low running costs like Toyota or Honda. The 500 requires full synthetic oil and OEM filters that cost more than standard ones. It needs fluid flushes and major services at fairly short intervals. The factory recommended maintenance schedule must be followed diligently to maintain the warranty. While not exorbitant, keeping a 500 running does require a bit higher of an annual maintenance budget for parts/labor than typical for its class.
Which model years and trim configurations of the Fiat 500 tend to be the most reliable used choices?
The most reliable used Fiat 500 model years are generally considered to be the 2015 and 2016 model years. These had fewer issues as Fiat continued improving the vehicle’s quality control and manufacturing since its 2011 reintroduction. Many major problems took a few years to get addressed and ironed out. The least reliable model years were early ones like 2012 where more bugs existed. As for trims, the base Pop with the naturally aspirated 1.4L engine, manual gearbox, and simpler features has proven the most durable and trouble-free over the long haul versus the more complex turbocharged trims. The automatic transmission is also known to be less reliable than the manual.
How expensive are Fiat 500 repairs and parts compared to other subcompact cars?
Repair costs for the Fiat 500 tend to run higher than repair costs for basic mainstream subcompact models like the Toyota Yaris, Nissan Versa, Hyundai Accent and Kia Rio that are optimized to be affordable to fix. OEM Fiat parts are pricier than these brands and some components require specialized tools not common in general repair shops. Repairs on complex systems like the dual-clutch transmission can cost upwards of $2000+ in some cases. Using non-OEM parts also risks inferior quality or improper fit. While not as costly as luxury brands, keeping an aging Fiat 500 on the road does typically cost more than basic transportation models when repairs are required.
Does the Fiat 500 cost more for gasoline than similar small cars?
The base Fiat 500 with the naturally aspirated 1.4L 4-cylinder engine delivers good fuel economy for the class, similar to competitors like the Hyundai Accent or Nissan Versa. Drivers can expect combined city/highway mileage around 30-32 mpg in real-world driving with the manual gearbox. However, the turbocharged variants do require premium fuel and have greater thirst under acceleration, reducing mileage to the high-20s mpg in combined driving. So there is a mileage penalty with the performance trims. Overall gas costs are pretty average for a subcompact car. The 500 doesn’t really excel or lag behind rivals in fuel efficiency unless opting for the more powerful turbo engine.
How safe is the Fiat 500? Does it have good crash test ratings?
Despite its small size, the Fiat 500 scores very well in government and industry crash testing, offering good occupant protection in accidents. It earns top 5-Star overall ratings from the NHTSA for frontal and side impact collisions. It gets a Top Safety Pick award from the IIHS as well when equipped with optional forward collision warning and lane departure warning technology. Advanced safety options like blind spot detection, rear cross path detection and parking sensors are also available. Size wise the 500 is comparable to rivals for passenger and cargo space. So safety does not have to be a concern for shoppers considering this stylish small car. It protects occupants as well as much larger vehicles.
Are Fiat 500s expensive to insure for teenage drivers?
Like most vehicles in its class, Fiat 500 models can be very costly for parents to insure for teenage drivers due to the high accident risk rates for this demographic. Average Fiat 500 insurance rates for teens run $400-$500 per month based on quotes from major Canadian providers. This factors in the higher repair costs, replacement parts prices, and claim frequency seen with the 500. Rates also assume minimum mandated liability and collision/comprehensive coverage. Teenage boys will pay the highest premiums, followed by teenage girls. Adding the car to a parent’s policy can save money if permissible. But overall, the 500 is not an affordable vehicle for teenage drivers from an insurance cost standpoint.
How much does it cost to replace the battery or tires on a Fiat 500?
Based on prices from leading Canadian retailers, owners can expect to pay approximately the following for these common replacement parts on a Fiat 500:
– Battery (OEM) – $180 to $250
– Set of tires (basic all-seasons) – $450 to $700
– Set of tires (high performance) – $650 to $950
Labor charges for installation and balancing will add around $100 or more to the tire quote. Using OEM Fiat batteries and tires ensures proper fit and performance while lower cost aftermarket brands can compromise safety or longevity. But owners do pay a premium over basic economy car parts. Checking for any pro-rated warranty coverage on the battery or tires can help defray replacement costs.
Are Fiat 500s expensive to customize or modify?
One attraction of the retro-styled Fiat 500 for many owners is the ability to customize or modify it to stand out from the crowd. However, transforming a 500 does carry higher costs than basic economy cars designed for minimal personalization. Custom upholstery, exterior wraps, performance upgrades, unique wheels and other enhancements do not come cheap due to required labor and use of OEM parts to maintain the warranty. Simple additions like graphics, decals, tinted windows or a rear spoiler offer more affordable ways to customize a 500 to suit personal tastes. But those seeking an extensively modified 500 should budget more for upgrades while factoring in potential reliability risks.
What expert sources provide the best reviews and rankings on Fiat 500 reliability?
Savvy used car shoppers researching the Fiat 500 should consult reliability data and rankings from these expert industry sources:
– Consumer Reports – Provides comprehensive reliability data on most models based on member surveys. Issues annual reliability reports.
– J.D. Power – Calculates quality and dependability scores based on verified owner surveys. Releases annual Vehicle Dependability Study.
– RepairPal – Rates models for reliability using repair data and calculates estimated ownership costs.
– LemonAid – Canadian market guide that summarizes problems for many vehicles going back years.
– Edmunds, CarComplaints, TrueDelta – Valuable databases of owners’ reported problems organized by year, model, and component.
– Fiat 500 online forums – Owners share maintenance costs, problems and repair advice. Provide real-world reliability insights.
How does the reliability of the Fiat 500 compare to the MINI Cooper?
The retro-styled MINI Cooper is probably the Fiat 500’s closest competitor as a European-flavored subcompact hatchback. Comparing their reliability reveals the following:
– The MINI scores a bit higher in most industry ratings for predicted reliability and ownership costs.
– Both models suffer electrical glitches, oil leaks, premature part failures, and sensor problems.
– MINI’s engine choices tend to be more robust and avoid issues like the 500’s troublesome dual clutch automatic transmission.
– Repair costs are high for both, but MINI parts may be slightly less expensive overall.
So while neither achieves Japanese levels of reliability, the MINI Cooper has proven to be the more durable and lower maintenance option over the life of the vehicle for those who prefer a European premium subcompact.
Are Fiat 500s expensive to maintain after the factory warranty expires?
Yes, Fiat 500 maintenance costs do increase after the 4 years/80,000 km factory warranty expires. No longer covered for free repairs of powertrain issues, owners must pay for problems previously covered like the water pump, turbo, transmission, electrical defects and more out of pocket which can be expensive. Required maintenance items like brake fluid flushes, gear oil changes, and belt/hose replacements also add up. Repair costs are higher than basic brands too. To keep an older 500 on the road and avoid surprise breakdowns, setting aside around $1,000 or more annually for maintenance beyond the warranty is recommended. The potential for expensive repairs always exists.
Is the Fiat 500 a good used car choice for students on a budget?
The stylish Fiat 500 may seem like an appealing used car for students seeking cheap, reliable transportation on a budget. But its higher ownership costs, repair bills, and spotty reliability make it a poor choice that can end up being quite expensive compared to more sensible options. Repairs, insurance, gas and maintenance all cost more for a 500. Things like oil changes must be done on time. Major issues can leave students without transportation and facing big bills. A used Honda Fit, Toyota Yaris, Hyundai Accent or Kia Rio are more prudent picks that maximize reliability and affordability for cash-strapped students.
What are the most common non-engine electrical problems with the Fiat 500?
The Fiat 500 has proven prone to a variety of frustrating electrical gremlins over its production life, especially in earlier model years before quality control improved. Some of the most commonly reported electrical defects from owners include:
– Faulty window regulators and switches
– Malfunctioning door locks and latches
– Glitchy climate control and HVAC systems
– Failures of interior lighting, gauges and warning lamps
– Radio/infotainment screen freezing up or dying
– Electrical shorts and blown fuses
– Faulty alarm system components
Diagnosing and repairing these types of gremlins can be time consuming and expensive for out of warranty models. Having complete electrical system inspections done prior to purchase is highly recommended for any used 500.
What are the most common engine and transmission issues with older Fiat 500 models?
Some of the most prevalent powertrain problems reported on higher-mileage Fiat 500 models outside of the factory warranty period include:
– Timing belt/chain failures in engines with higher mileage
– Leaking gaskets and seals causing oil leaks
– Excessive oil consumption and fouled spark plugs
– Premature clutch wear and failures in manual models
– Leaking input shaft seals on manual gearboxes
– Expensive failures of the dual clutch automatic transmission
– Turbo failures in turbocharged engines
– Ignition coil and spark plug failures
Having compression tests, leak down checks and transmission inspections done by a trusted mechanic when buying an older 500 minimizes risks of imminent engine or gearbox repairs.
What's the bottom line on whether the Fiat 500 is worth buying used?
The bottom line is the Fiat 500 makes for a very high-risk used car purchase compared to rival models unless found at a significant discount in price. Its below average reliability scores, higher ownership costs, expensive OEM parts and repair bills make it difficult to justify over more tried-and-true used economy cars. While its retro style and driving dynamics appeal to many, it’s best suited to buyers who won’t depend on it as their sole vehicle and can afford surprise repairs. For most Canadian used car shoppers, a Fiat 500 ranks low on the list of recommended purchases due to reliability shortcomings. Thorough inspections and maintenance diligence are musts.
